Are Expensive Cat Toys a Scam? Discover These Mind-Blowing DIY Alternatives

Ever notice how store-bought cat toys can be pricey and sometimes don’t even hold your kitty’s interest for long?

I’ve been there too, and that’s why I dove into the world of DIY cat toys.

Not only are they budget-friendly, but they’re also a fantastic way to repurpose items you already have at home.

Benefits of DIY Cat Toys

Store-bought cat toys can be expensive and often fail to keep our catfriends entertained. DIY cat toys, on the other hand, offer several benefits that make them a great alternative.

Affordable and Accessible

First off, making your own cat toys is super affordable.

You don’t need to spend a fortune on fancy gadgets when household items work just as well. Got some old socks or cardboard boxes lying around?


These common items can be turned into fun and engaging toys for your cat at little to no cost.

Plus, DIY projects are accessible to everyone. No special skills are required—just a bit of creativity.

For example, you can turn a toilet paper roll into a treat dispenser by cutting holes in it and stuffing it with kibble.

It’s easy, quick, and doesn’t require any expensive materials.

Customizable for Your Cat

DIY cat toys also allow for customization tailored to your cat‘s preferences.

Every cat is unique, so why settle for generic store-bought options?

If your kitty loves chasing strings, you can create a toy using yarn and feathers.

On the other hand, if they prefer batting around small objects, crumpled-up paper balls could become their new favorite plaything.

Also, you get to experiment and see what works best for your furry friend.

Maybe they’re bored of their current toy selection; creating new ones keeps things fresh and exciting for them.

Variety keeps cats mentally stimulated and physically active—key factors in their overall health.

Essential Tools and Materials

Creating DIY cat toys is a fun, budget-friendly activity. But before diving in, it’s crucial to have the right tools and materials.

Basic Tools Needed

For DIY cat toys, you’ll need simple tools that are likely already in your toolkit:

  • Scissors: These are essential for cutting fabric, string, or cardboard.
  • Hot Glue Gun: Ideal for securely attaching materials together.
  • Needle and Thread: Handy for sewing small toys or repairing worn ones.
  • Craft Knife: Useful for detailed cutting work on tougher materials like cardboard.

You probably have most of these items at home. If not, they’re easily found at local stores or online.

Sourcing Affordable Materials

You don’t need to expensive with expensive supplies.

Look around your home first; you’d be surprised how many items can be repurposed into cat toys.

  • Old Socks: Perfect for creating soft, snuggly toys.
  • Cardboard Boxes: Cats love playing with boxes, which can be transformed into tunnels or scratching posts.
  • Feathers and String: Use these to make enticing dangly toys.
  • Plastic Bottles and Caps: Great for rolling toys that cats can chase around.

Thrift stores or dollar stores are also fantastic places to find cheap materials. Sometimes you might even strike gold in clearance bins!

Popular Types of DIY Cat Toys

There are so many fun ways to keep your cat entertained with DIY toys.

It’s amazing how much joy they can get from homemade creations.

Interactive Wand Toys

Interactive wand toys stimulate a cat‘s natural hunting instincts.

They love the thrill of chasing and pouncing. I often use a simple stick or dowel as the base.

Attach feathers, ribbons, or even old fabric strips at the end using string or non-toxic glue.

Cats go wild for these!

You can swap out attachments to keep things exciting. Just ensure that all materials are securely attached to avoid any choking hazards.

Puzzle Feeders for Cats

Puzzle feeders add a mental challenge to mealtime, which helps prevent boredom and obesity in cats.

I’ve found that cardboard tubes from toilet paper rolls make great puzzle feeder bases.

Cut small holes in them and fill with dry food or treats – cats will spend hours figuring out how to get their tasty reward.

Alternatively, you can use plastic bottles by cutting holes just large enough for kibble to fall through when batted around.

Step-by-Step Guide to Making DIY Cat Toys

Making DIY cat toys isn’t just cost-effective; it’s also a great way to bond with your furry friend.

Let’s jump into some easy projects you can tackle at home.

Creating a Simple Cat Wand

First up, we’ll make a cat wand. These are fantastic for engaging your cat‘s hunting instincts.

  1. Gather Materials: You’ll need a stick or dowel, some string, and attachments like feathers or ribbons.
  2. Prepare the Stick: Ensure the stick is smooth and free of splinters. If it’s too rough, sand it down a bit.
  3. Attach the String: Tie one end of the string securely around the top of the stick.
  4. Add Attachments: On the other end of the string, tie on feathers or ribbons—whatever catches your cat’s eye.

You can get creative with this step if you’ve got extra craft supplies lying around. Some folks even add small bells for an auditory element.

Designing Puzzle Feeders

Next, let’s create puzzle feeders—perfect for mental stimulation during meal times.

  1. Collect Supplies: Grab empty cardboard tubes (like toilet paper rolls) or plastic bottles, scissors, and treats or dry food.
  2. Cut Holes: If using cardboard tubes, cut small holes along the sides large enough for treats to fall out but not too big that they’re easily accessible.
  3. Assemble Feeder: For plastic bottles, remove labels and ensure they’re clean. Cut out holes similarly sized.
  4. Fill with Treats: Place treats or kibble inside and let your cat figure out how to get them out.

Try varying the size of the holes based on your cat’s skill level to keep things challenging but not frustrating.

Tips for Safety and Maintenance

When making DIY cat toys, keeping your catfriend safe and happy is a top priority.

I’ll share practical tips to ensure your homemade creations are both enjoyable and secure.

Safety Precautions

Start by picking the right materials.

Avoid small parts that could be choking hazards, sharp edges that might cause injuries, or toxic substances that cats might ingest.

For example, if you’re using string or yarn, make sure it’s sturdy enough not to break into small pieces.

Keep an eye on playtime.

Supervise your cat when introducing a new toy to spot any potential dangers early on.

Does the toy have loose parts? Is there anything your cat‘s trying to chew off?

Your vigilance can prevent accidents before they happen.

Consider your cat‘s behavior.

Some cats are more aggressive chewers than others.

If yours tends to shred toys quickly, opt for more durable materials like heavy-duty fabric or rubber.

On the flip side, gentle players might enjoy softer materials like felt or fleece.

Maintaining and Repairing Toys

Regular maintenance keeps toys fun and safe.

Inspect toys weekly for wear and tear—check strings for fraying, attachments for looseness, and fabric for holes.

Fix minor issues immediately with glue or stitching before they become bigger problems.

Cleanliness matters too.

Many toys can get pretty grimy over time, especially those used with treats or food.

Wash fabric toys in warm water with mild soap every couple of weeks (or as needed).

Plastic toys can often be wiped down with a damp cloth or soaked in soapy water.

Set aside a repair kit with basic supplies like needle and thread, non-toxic glue, extra feathers, and spare ribbons.

This way, you’re always ready to do quick fixes without much hassle.

By following these tips on safety and maintenance, you’ll ensure your DIY cat toys remain enjoyable and safe for your furry friend.


Creating DIY cat toys isn’t just cost-effective; it’s also a fun way to bond with your catfriend.

Seeing my cat‘s excitement when playing with something I’ve made is incredibly rewarding. Plus I can tailor the toys to suit her unique preferences and ensure she’s always mentally and physically stimulated.

Remember safety first! Always use non-toxic materials and supervise playtime. Regularly inspect the toys for wear and tear to keep them safe and enjoyable.

So next time you’re tempted by a pricey store-bought toy consider making one yourself. Your cat will love it and you’ll enjoy the process too!

Similar Posts